Homes with Lake Toxaway Frontage for Sale

MLS Number 106456

• Residential
• Bedrooms 4
• Bathroom 7
• Acreage 1.12

One of Lake Toxaway and Western North Carolina's most magnificent legacy homes, this masterfully crafted 4BR, 5.5BA estate is situated on two prime lakefront point lots with 326 feet of lake frontage on fabled Lake Toxaway. Situated very close to the Lake Toxaway Country Club, Greystone Inn, Marina, and all amenities Lake Toxaway offers, this Old World Estate offers the finest appointments including extensive stone work, large, spacious rooms, three wood burning masonry fireplaces, chef's kitchen, expansive master suite with en-suite paneled library, gracious guest suites upstairs, bonus room with full bath over a two car garage, generator, golf cart garage, extensive outdoor entertaining spaces including a covered dining porch, firepit, large stationary dock, two stall boat house, and one of the most spectacular lake and mountain views in the mountains of North Carolina. This home is a rare opportunity and a must see.

Listed by Amanda Jennings Gravley of Fisher Realty Sapphire/Toxaway

MLS Number 1000926

• Residential
• Bedrooms 4
• Bathroom 6
• Acreage 0.68

Meticulously crafted 4 BR, 5.5 Ba custom home with level circular drive on magnificent site overlooking Lake Toxaway and Toxaway Mountain. Many custom features include a large great room with soaring ceilings and a large stone wood-burning fireplace. Well equipped chef's kitchen featuring Viking Oven/range, two dishwashers, large kitchen island for entertaining, elevator, extensive built-ins, attached garage/carport, expansive back covered porch and pavered cart path from the home to the lake, boathouse, and extensive docking make this home a legacy lake house in beautiful Lake Toxaway.

Listed by Amy Fisher of Fisher Realty Brevard

MLS Number 104744

• Residential
• Bedrooms 3
• Bathroom 4
• Acreage 0.81

A RARE opportunity to have a flat lake lot and beautiful long view! This home is on a quiet road on a peaceful protected spot on the lake. 2 suites plus a 3rd bedroom and bath on the main floor. A spacious great room, kitchen and dining area that all have lake view. Easy access to roofed deck and yard from great room/dining area and master bedroom. Floor to ceiling stone fireplace and built-ins in great room. Exquisite wainscoting throughout. High ceilings and 8 foot sliding doors. Large kitchen island with room for bar stools. Large master suite has lake view and is off to one side for privacy and quiet. Also has adequate room for sitting area. Master bathroom has separate toilet/bidet room and soaking tub. Custom plantation shutters in bedroom and bath. Lots of cabinet space. Central vac system. Downstairs features a family room with built-ins and walk out to yard. Also a full bath and additional room for workout and for a bunk room. A large unfinished space that would be perfect for media room or workshop. Big laundry/pantry (drop zone) off the garage. Circular drive and 2 car garage on the .81 ac property. This is a one owner, custom built home designed by the owner. Split zone HVAC replaced in 2024. Water filtration system and water softener. According to floor plans HLA is approx. 4130 sq.ft. (2718 approx. on main floor).

Listed by Kathryn Balistreri of Balistreri Realty

MLS Number 106458

• Residential
• Bedrooms 3
• Bathroom 5
• Acreage 3.05

Discover a one-of-a-kind retreat in the heart of Lake Toxaway Estates, where rustic charm meets refined luxury. Situated on over 3 private acres, this estate-like property blends timeless design with modern comforts-all with exclusive access to Lake Toxaway. Step inside the main home to find an open, light-filled floor plan, where a double-sided stone fireplace anchors the spacious living and dining areas. The upscale kitchen is outfitted with high-end finishes and offers a seamless flow to the sunlit dining area, which overlooks the manicured lawn and lake beyond. The private primary suite is a true sanctuary, featuring its own fireplace, sitting area, and a private porch-perfect for quiet mornings or evening sunsets. Each guest suite includes an en-suite bath, ensuring comfort and privacy. The finished lower level adds exceptional flexibility, offering a second kitchenette, bonus room, full bath, and laundry space. Step outside and be transported by the presence of a beautifully preserved antique cabin, complete with a kitchen, full bath, and wood-burning fireplace. Whether used as a guest cottage or private escape, it adds a rare, storybook touch to the property. This is more than a home -it's a home of distinction, offering boulder-accented landscaping, mountain and lake views. A true gem for those seeking rustic elegance in a pristine mountain setting.

Listed by Amanda Jennings Gravley of Fisher Realty Sapphire/Toxaway

MLS Number 1002192

• Residential
• Bedrooms 3
• Bathroom 4
• Acreage 0.74

Set along the peaceful shores of Lake Toxaway, this inviting lakefront home offers the perfect mix of mountain comfort and lakeside living. Expansive views of the lake fill nearly every room, creating a calm and welcoming atmosphere from the moment you step inside. The open floor plan makes it easy to gather with family and friends, whether you're cooking together in the spacious kitchen or relaxing by one of two wood-burning fireplaces. The main-level primary suite is a quiet retreat with its own private balcony overlooking the water, while two additional bedrooms share a convenient Jack and Jill bath. Downstairs, a second living area, full bath, game room, and workshop provide plenty of flexible space for guests or hobbies. Outdoor living takes center stage with a large screened porch on the main level and an expansive patio-both perfect for enjoying the fresh mountain air and long summer evenings by the lake. The property's large flat backyard, perfect for all your recreational activities, stretches to the shoreline, where a two-bay boathouse makes it easy to spend your days on the water. A two-car garage and generous laundry room add practical convenience to this well-designed home. Tucked along one of Lake Toxaway's most desirable stretches of shoreline, this property offers a rare chance to enjoy relaxed, lakefront living in a truly special mountain setting. North Eastshore Drive provides an inviting, walkable setting that's perfect for relaxing evening strolls, all while being just a short drive from the charming mountain towns of Cashiers and Brevard. Membership to Lake Toxaway Country Club is based upon application and availability.

Listed by Ross Hyett of Lake Toxaway Company

MLS Number 1001374

• Condo Residential
• Bedrooms 2
• Bathroom 3
• Acreage 0.02

This lakefront condo has been updated throughout and features 2 bedrooms, 2 full baths, one half bath and a bonus room. Offered beautifully furnished, with exceptions. Step outside to the stone patio, perfect for grilling and entertaining al fresco. The interior dining area is complete with a wet bar and opens to the beautifully renovated kitchen. Settle in by the fireplace after the sun goes down and enjoy the porch and gorgeous lake views. Retire to the primary en-suite above it all with spaces thoughtfully designed for efficiency and organization. Toxaway Shores has all the coveted amenities - private pool, private tennis/pickleball court, a wrap-around dock with your own boat slip, a community clubhouse and a lush green lawn to enjoy all the summer activities. Enjoy maintenance-free living in this condo on the lake.

Listed by Judith Maureen Mitchell and Mish Nichols of Lake Toxaway Company